Well, I'm finishing up another CD this week, but the T-Lou CD is out and people liked the art, so I'm going to talk through how we came to the final art. Oh, and by the way, if you want to buy the album on iTunes, you can do it here. Unsure when the CD is going to show up on Amazon...
First, we'll talk about what the client brought to the table. They wanted something that said "party" and "Zydeco" and "fun" with the artist front and center, since it's been a really long time since his last record. We needed to position the talent front and center. The producer sent me a few dozen images as reference, which included:
Essentially, focus on bright colors that conjure a Louisiana feel and the outsized personality of T-Lou.
My first recommendation was to schedule a photo shoot with T-Lou. The images from the studio (taken with a good camera by the producer) were still not good enough to make beautiful key art, so we needed new photography. Fortunately, I've been doing quite a bit of work with my new Canon 7D, so we scheduled the shoot and went to work. Several hundred shots later, here are some of the highlights:
So we now have great key art: the artist and the producer were both really happy with the proofs from the shoot.
Now it was my turn to interpret what feel they were looking for. Let's look at some of the different concept pieces that I presented to the artist and the producer at our first design presentation:
Interestingly, the first proof is the one that is closest to the final. I went for a big and bold typeface, an image of T-Lou loving' life and playin' music, and some "dancing" crabs to tie into the album's title. I was unsure about the crabs, because they kinda looked like the tripod aliens from Wells' "War of the Worlds," but this was first proof territory, so everything is fair game.
Now I got even bolder and funkier. There were these pictures where T-Lou just looks badass, so I married that up with some distressed type and some pretty heavy color correction (lots of desaturation, but adding contrast), and we get this beautiful bold look. But then why can't I take it one step further?...
I think this might be my favorite design from the first round. I made the T-Lou art bigger and happier, and pulled all the color out of his photo. All of a sudden he pops off the CD cover. Still using distressed type on the artist name, but really clean on the album title. Simple and bold...perfect.
But my concern with the previous art was that it was getting way too non-traditional for a genre that has lots of tradition in it. So I tried a few looks that sit more comfortably within the established "look" of Zydeco artists. This first one has some issues, because T-Lou feels a little too low, and the ratio/balance between him, his name, and the album title just seems off. But still a good exercise, and if the client had liked it, we could have worked all of those issues out...
And then I went completely traditional. We added a sepia look to a non-retouched photo, did the "type on a curve" thing that lots of oldies/traditional albums do, and still added a crab — more now as just a graphic element — to keep it fun and tied-in with the album title.
Still loving the "badass T-Lou" look, I couldn't resist doing something completely different. This keeps my mind fresh, and shows the client that there are options out there. If they don't like something here, we can go a completely different direction. I had downloaded the curly background art from iStockphoto a few weeks previous for another project (that didn't end up getting made) — it was originally blue — repurposed it for this proof by making it gold/brown and framing the artist. The type glows; the whole thing says "me and my accordion are not to be messed with." Cool.
So wait, I had pretty much ignored the "let's make it colorful" request from the client, so I did one with everything but the kitchen sink. The mardi gras feathers, some New Orleans brick in the background, a wood sign from a beach somewhere — making it bold and messy and colorful.You will notice that I didn't just present the artwork in a square on a piece of paper. I snagged a CD I had photographed from another project, and superimposed the T-Lou artwork onto that photograph. I believe that one extra step — making the art look like the final packaging — gives the client a much better idea of what his CD will look like once everything is done and shipping.
Well, the clients flipped — they loved that first round of proofs. The energy, the photography, even lots of the typefaces chosen, were really making T-Lou excited.They loved the crabs, but didn't think they were "fun" enough, so I suggested maybe adding some cartoon eyes that I had found but discarded while working on the first set of design ideas. They liked that. So we decided to work on revising the first proof to everyone's liking.T-Lou comes from Louisiana, and really wanted the Louisiana coast to play a large role in the art. While almost all of the backgrounds are of Gulf Coast beaches, I had bleached out the colors of the backgrounds to focus attention on the artist. T-Lou said no, we want to see the blue of the ocean and the sky; adding back more colors would get us to that "make it colorful" initial request, too.T-Lou also doesn't like sans serif typefaces that much; he likes the refinement and formality of serif type better. So I needed to give him some options with different typefaces, since that first proof had the really big, thick, sans serif type for the "T-LOU" at the top.So here is what we delivered for a second round:
Blue ocean, crabs with cartoon eyes, curved serif type across the top. Nice.
Maybe using the beach/weathered wood signpost plus the cartoon-y crabs? And we have a really bold typeface for "T-LOU," but it still has serifs on it. Tricky, aren't I?
Now here I have used the same design as above, but changed the colors up to see what happens. The light green allows the crabs to move to the forefront (the yellow was pretty strong), but I'm still not sure if the balance is right.
Ah, so the honkin' big type was the problem. Pull that out, and replace it with a very refined slab serif, and the balance between all of the elements on the cover works out. So what did we accomplish? A few things:
The finished product! If I get around to it, I'll take pictures of the traycard and CD face, which look awesome too. But for now, we see how I got from the client's initial design brief to the final product. Everyone is very pleased with the outcome.